Let's roll some dice, watch some movies, or generally just geek out. New posts at 6:30 pm ET but only if I have something to say. Menu at the top. gsllc@chirp.enworld.org on Mastodon and @gsllc on Twitter.
Based on some test scenarios of my own, I’ve been examining the combat efficiency (CE) system in FASA Star Trek RPG. Quite frankly, it’s a terrible metric for predicting the balance of an encounter, and many agree. Moreover, because this was developed in the 80s, the number of typos in the official publications resulted in the system not being faithfully represented by the game designers. However, because it’s part of the ruleset, I’m not eliminating it from my FASA Star Trek VTT/Bridge applications. I am, however, giving you another option.
Fleet Strength Points
This system calculates the Ship Strength Rating (SSR) of a ship. This is a grade for a single ship that falls between 0 and 100. It’s the ship’s average result against every other ship in the game. An SSR of 50 is average; an SSR of 90 means the ship beats almost every ship in the FASA universe. This number represents a direct comparison between two ships and should never be added to another ship’s SSR. That’s where Fleet Strength Points (FSP) enters. A ship’s FSP is a value designed to be added up. Add the FSP of every ship on a side and compare the totals: A side with twice the FSP of the other side should usually win. The median warship is worth about 10 points.
Both come from simulated one-on-one duels between every pair of armed ships, at short, medium, and long range using the Advanced rules. Each duel uses the ship’s real superstructure, engine power, shields, weapons, firing arcs, to-hit charts, and damage table. Each ship splits its power between movement, shields, and weapons, and fires its full volley in one firing phase to break through the enemy’s shield. Penetrating damage follows the Advanced damage table: superstructure, engine power, shield generators, and weapons. SSR is the ship’s average result. FSP turns each duel’s kill times into an additive value using Lanchester’s square law, a classic model of fleet combat.
How Does It Compare to CE?
Power can be spent only once. CE credits the same engine power twice: once in the Defense Factor (movement and shields) and again in the Weapon Damage Factor, which assumes every weapon is fully powered at once. The SSR makes each ship divide its power between movement, shields, and weapons.
Firing arcs. CE counts every weapon whatever its arc. The SSR counts only the weapons that bear on the target.
Range. CE is a single number. The SSR is worked out at short, medium, and long range, so brawlers and stand-off ships are both rated fairly.
Hull strength. CE values superstructure as if most penetrating damage hits it. Under the Advanced damage table only 30% does, so sturdy hulls last longer than CE suggests.
Damage that wears a ship down. Engine hits reduce power, and weapon and shield-generator hits remove systems. The duels play this out turn by turn.
Cloaking devices. A cloaked ship can close unseen and strike an unshielded facing, but it pays the cloak’s power that turn. The relatively cheap Romulan cloaks gain a few points from this; costly Klingon cloaks rarely do.
Clean data. CE depends on published D and WDF values, many of which contain typos. SSR and FSP are calculated directly from each ship’s components.
What Doesn’t This Take into Account?
The FSP doesn’t taken into account maneuvering skill, shield-facing play, evasion, crew quality, Graduate or Command & Control effects, and battle tactics involving several ships at once. Like CE, SSR and FSP are nothing more than a good guide as to who usually wins a straight fight, not a prediction of any one battle where player skill can override the mechanics anyway. However, I suspect FSP is a better predictor of combat side strength even if not perfect, and the only way to know is to test it with real humans playing it.
If you know of any combats that are even, add them to the battle map and let me know if they made a fair prediction.
I announced my FASA Star Trek RPG VTT some time ago, but all it represented was a digital battle map that can be used standalone. Now, the second component has made enough progress to release the beta version. I call the second component Bridge. It manages the master control panels, which are analogous to character sheets but for starships, using the second edition ruleset. While also able to be used standalone, using them together is where they really shine. Before explaining how to use Bridge with the VTT, let me first give you the very basics as to how to use the system, then point you to the VTT help file that provides more details.
Some of what I describe here won’t make sense until you read the section below entitled, “It’s Not All Good News.” I’ve tried to identify and label all such items “(q.v.).” Also of note, I often assume you know how to play the game (2nd edition rules).
Play with the default test ships if you want to get the hang of things, but when you’re ready . . . .
Click Join Room on the right-hand menu.
Enter a room number, your name (must be unique per room number), a password for your other players to use to enter, select Create New Room, and enter an admin password (must be different from the regular password) that allows you to retake control of the room if you’re dropped. Your players will ignore the checkbox and admin password
As admin, when you create the room, you’ll be given a participants dialog box (see image below) where you assign each player to a side. Even if two players are playing allied forces, it will be better if they’re treated as different sides. You should wait until everyone has joined before closing the dialog box, but you may always reopen it by clicking Participants on the right-hand menu.
Once a player (including the admin) is assigned a side, that player can start placing ships on the battle map. If you want the ship to initially be invisible when placed, make sure Visible on Placement is unchecked. Uncloaked ships should be visible from the start (unless hidden behind a planet, etc.), so make sure that check box is checked if your ship isn’t going to be cloaked to start the encounter.
To add a ship, go to the bottom of the right-hand menu, find your government, expand the menu, find the ship type, expand that menu, then click on the relevant ship. This places you in Placement Mode. Click on a hex, and the ship’s silhouette will be placed. You may also add “obstacles,” which include stars, planets, moons, asteroids, wreckage, anomalies, black holes, and space dust, all of varying sizes. When you’ve placed all your assets, click the slowly flashing Cancel Placement button on the right-hand menu.
Right click on your ship to change its name, side, controlling player, visibility, movement points (unnecessary with Bridge), or delete the ship altogether. (Clicking Clear Battlefield on the right-hand menu clears all ships, but only the admin can do that.
If the admin isn’t playing as a GM, the admin should uncheck Admin Sees All on the right-hand menu so that cloaked ships and ships behind obstacles are invisible to the admin.
You can use the Participants dialog box to boot an unruly player, then check the Lock Room checkbox on the right-hand menu to require admin approval before letting someone back in the room even if they know the password. If they keep spamming you with requests to enter, you can click ignore to ignore their future requests.
Finally, click Room Settings on the right-side menu to open the Room Settings dialog box (see image below) assign a ruleset (avoid C&C for now) and warp speed at which the encounter takes place.
If you’re ever stuck wondering how to do something, hold down the O key, and you’ll see a partial list of controls appear on the left side of the screen. These include controls for manipulating the battle map itself (e.g., zoom in, zoom out, panning). The left side display includes a lot of useful information, so make sure to take a look at it.
Bridge
This application doesn’t have a help file, so it’s going to take a bit more to help you along with it. Still, I think a lot of it is intuitive, so you may just want to learn through doing rather than reading about it. In case not, here’s some help with some visual aids.
First up is the top of the screen and your engineering panel.
Engineering console and some stuff for the Captain’s Console when it’s ready.
The top identifies your ship, the turn number, rule set, encounter speed, and phase. It also provides for skill rolls (crew efficiency in Advanced and Graduate; Skill Rolls in C&C) and later will provide for other decisions (q.v.) generally reserved for the Captain. Once we have a Captain’s Console (q.v.), these will be far better organized. As you can see, you may roll automatically or roll with dice and enter your roll manually. The admin/GM will eventually be able to forbid manual rolls, but for now, they’re allowed. If you don’t want to use them, you don’t have to. Just agree not to use them until the switch is enabled.
You’ll also notice the yellow button. Sometimes there are six ships on the battle map, but only four are currently fighting (e.g., the other two represent a second wave of ships that enter in turn 3). In that case, the game gets held up because not all ships have allocated power yet. The Advanced Without Missing Ships button appears on all of the admin’s ships and allows the admin to advance the game without the missing ships. The missing ships won’t be able to join combat until the first phase of the following turn. If they attempt to enter early, they’re placed in a waiting room with a disabled Join button that becomes enabled as soon as they’re able to join.
Below these is the Engineering console. There, you enter the amount of power allocated to shields and weapons (and cloaking device if you have one), with the remaining available power automatically being allocated to movement. To the left, it warns you if you’re wasting power because of the movement point ratio. That is, if your movement point ratio is 4/1, but the amount of power to movement is not evenly divisible by four, then you’re wasting some power points. Also, using the menu on the left side of the screen, you may jump to the Weapons console and arm weapons before allocating power to weapons, then jump back to the Engineering console where you’ll be told how much power you allocated to weapons. That makes it easy to enter the correct allocation. With shields, you must allocate power before you can assign shield points, so jump to Navigation, look at your shield point ratio, and allocate accordingly.
If you lower your allocation to shields after assigning shield points or fail to allocate weapons, or fail to execute your skill rolls, the Complete Power Allocation button will be disabled. Once those three tasks are performed, the button will be enabled, and you should click it. Then you’ll be jumped automatically to the Science console for the Sensors phase (or to the Helm in the Basic ruleset).
Next up are the Navigation and Science consoles.
Navigation and Science Consoles
Navigation: You’ll be told how many shield points you have available to allocate. Allocate (or deallocate) them by clicking the appropriate lamp. (I call these lamps because they’re meant to emulate the lights on the original series consoles.) A few notes. If a shield generator is damaged, the lamps will all be red. If destroyed, they’ll become very dark grey (essentially black). If the shield is hit and temporarily expended, the amount by which it’s been expended will turn yellow. Finally, if power has been temporarily reduced due to engine damage, the lamps will turn orange (with green lettering) to the extent they’re reduced in power. If the engines are repaired during the current turn, the lamps will light green again.
Science: Outside of Basic, you have two choices for sensors. First, you may select a visible ship and attempt to lock onto it. If you succeed, the first dropdown list (“Select a question”) will be enabled, and depending on which question you select, another dropdown list may be enabled for follow up. Second, you may instead search for cloaked ships. You must select an arc to search, and then roll to see if you detect anything.
Now, on to the Helm.
Helm Console
At the top left, you see the current speed of the encounter highlighted and outlined. You also can see the speeds you can change to without a skill roll (highlighted but not outlined). To the top right, you can see that it’s your turn to move. Other ships will have the message, “Waiting on ship #1 to complete movement.” In fact, similar messages will appear throughout the control panel so that if someone doesn’t realize it’s their turn, you may (politely, I hope) let them know that everyone is waiting on them. To the left, you can see diagrams showing the various legal movements available, each costing a movement point to execute. These will be lit up and selectable. Selecting one moves that action into the queue on the right, then adjusts the hex diagram to show how the ship will be repositioned on the map once you’ve made your final decision. None are currently lit up because all movement points have been used to queue actions. Also, this helm was printed in Basic, so the third row (reverse movement options) aren’t present. If you moved forward in this or the last movement phase, then the reverse movements will be unavailable and thus dimmed out. As for the buttons, clicking undo removes the last entry in the queue, clicking clear removes all entries in the queue (essentially starting over), clicking Hold the Rest fills the rest of the queue with holding station (if you have more movement points than you need for the phase), and Emer Port and Emer Stbd are enabled if making an emergency heading change is available at the moment (along with a warning in red text as to the damage your ship will take from the stress of such a heading change). Once you’re satisfied with how your ship will be moved, you should click Commit, your ship’s bearing and position will be updated on the VTT, and the next player in tactical order will then have their Helm enabled after reviewing how you moved.
Here’s an image from the Graduate ruleset showing some of the missing features.
You can see some of the hexes filled in. That’s because the ship is navigating around a planet. You can also see reverse movement dimmed because of the forward movement, and one forward movement dimmed because it would cause a collision with the planet. The others are still lit and can be clicked to add to the queue that’s not full. Because one of the movements involved starboard rotation, the ship now has the ability to rotate an additional hex side as an emergency heading change; hence, the enabled button.
I intend to allow the admin to employ a house rule requiring all movement to be performed at the same time, but the rules don’t read that way, so it hasn’t been implemented yet. Note that such a house rule practically eliminates tactical advantage from the game, so I can’t make it the default rule.
After this movement, you’ll then have three more buttons appear, replacing those five.
Everyone will be given the option of a tactical heading change to port or starboard, or in the alternative No Change (with the appropriate warning text for damage). In other words, the movement phase is divided into two segments: normal movement (performed in tactical advantage order) and then tactical heading (performed simultaneously).
Warping out (not shown here) is implemented from the Helm but during different phases depending on the ruleset. The skill roll allowing a ship to warp out by a change in two warp factors is handled during the C&C skill roll phase, and if the engineer’s roll succeeds, additional warp speed lamps are lit.
This is the last Helm image you’re going to get.
Now that you’ve moved, it’s on to weapons.
Weapons Console
Like the Helm, the Weapons phase is divided into multiple segments, but more than just two. In the first segment, everyone simultaneously chooses which weapons to fire. If a weapon has no valid targets, you won’t be able to fire it no matter how many times you press the button. You’ll get a message telling you so. Once you’re done with your selections, if you aren’t firing all weapons, you’ll need to hit the Weapons Ready button to proceed. Everyone will receive a message that they’re waiting for others to compete their firing selections. Note: There’s now a Fire All button that fires all weapons that have valid targets that aren’t allies. If you click that, those weapons fire, and you won’t have to click Weapons Ready. This brings you to the targeting segment (which will eventually be merged into the weapons console rather than appear below it).
Targeting
Here, you can see that the bottom weapon hasn’t yet chosen its target. In this case, there’s only one valid target, but there will be a list of multiple valid targets where such targets exist. The top weapon has already chosen its target and therefore displays a message that it’s waiting for other ships to choose theirs. Once everyone has chosen their targets, we move on to the attack and damage resolution segment.
Hitting and Resolving Damage
The top weapon has already rolled its (successful) to-hit die. It therefore received a message as to how much penetrating damage was done, so now the player is being asked how to resolve such damage. So, what if the weapon is a missile weapon (i.e., photon torpedo, energy torpedo, or Romulan plasma torpedo)? Then the target ship’s console is jumped to Incoming.
The target ship gets a chance to evade either to port or starboard. But this is a Romulan plasma torpedo, so in addition to evasion, there’s an additional option.
Here, the captain may attempt a skillful maneuver. Again, all of these options will be better organized on the Captain’s console (q.v.) once it exists.
Okay, I skipped one: the Damage Control console. In Basic and Advanced, it’s boring. It’s just shows superstructure. So, here it is in Graduate.
Damage Control Console
Maybe that’s still boring, but as a ship gets damaged, the Damage Control console will provide options for repairs.
Like so.
The Use Manual Roll button will be much clearer if you enter a roll in the text box. Basic doesn’t allow repairs, Advanced doesn’t allow repairs of weapons, and C&C allows repairs but without a separate Repair/Repower phase. So, there are a few different ways repairs are dealt with on this console. If you understand it in one ruleset, you’ll have no problem adjusting to the others.
Update for 11/16/2026: Command & Control
As I said, C&C isn’t ready for prime time; however, it’s coming along rather nicely. Among many other things (e.g., implementation of Engineering Out, shaken officers), you now have a random crew assigned to your ship. You may access it by clicking the Crew button just above the skill rolls during the skill rolls phase. The image below also shows two optional rules that I’ll get to in a moment.
Clicking Crew brings you to the following page.
This page contains the name, rank, assignment (i.e., ship assignment such as Engineer or Damage Control Officer), and skill ratings for each crew member. Behind the scenes, it also creates a hierarchy of rank such that if the Captain is shaken, the next person in line of command now makes the tactical advantage roll using their Starship Combat Strategy/Tactics rating. (The Captain being shaken can occur only through one of the house rules that, again, I’ll go over shortly.) The engineer is presumed to be in engineering and therefore does not fall in that line of command during a combat. As you can probably deduce, the information can be revised to change anything about these characters. In addition, a character, or the entire crew, can be saved and reloaded at a later date. Expanding the list of skills (as was done for the Chief Engineer) shows all the skills that Bridge tracks. Bridge is not a character builder, so the list is not complete. Skills are divided into primary skills for an officers assignment (3d10+45), two secondary skills chosen as a “minor” (3d10+39), and tertiary skills (2d10+20).
I will be creating crews published by FASA and add links to them below when they’re ready. This will include not only the crew of the USS Enterprise but also crews from the adventures published by FASA. If anyone beats me to the punch and creates them first, please send them to me.
House Rule: Captain’s Orders
We’ve seen it many times. The ship takes a hit, the crew are thrown around and/or a panel explodes, and one officer is shaken. The game contemplates this. But what if the weapons officer is injured? Firing weapons is fairly important, and a shaken officer can’t do that. Captain’s Orders allows another officer to abandon his or her post and take over for the weapons officer. At the end of a firing phase in which at least one officer is shaken, the Captain is given the choice to reassign officers to other posts to make sure critical consoles are not left unmanned. Engineering is left out of this carousel because it’s located in a different part of the ship. Only the bridge crew can be shuffled, and additional characters can’t be brought to the bridge fast enough during an encounter. However, the Captain represents a free officer substitute that can take over a station. There are only two downsides to doing so. First, for tactical advantage, the Captain loses the 1d10 roll to add to his or her Starship Combat Strategy/Tactics rating due to the distraction of manning a post. Second, once the Captain has taken over a console, the Captain can be shaken. That is, when the “Navigator” is shaken, it’s not actually Fred Snerd the Navigator that’s shaken, but rather whatever officer is currently assigned to the Navigation console. If the Captain has taken over Navigation, and the “Navigator is shaken,” the Captain needs to make a DEX save or else be shaken. Like all house rules, this rule is off by default.
House Rule: Firing While Cloaked
In case you have a Star Trek VI situation, the admin is given the option to allow cloaked ships to fire weapons. There are plenty of ships in the FASA universe that have enough power to cloak and arm weapons. By default, they cannot fire while cloaked.
All of these house rule options will be moved from the ship page to the dialog boxes where games are created. For now, they appear at the top of all ships run by the admin (whether the admin is a GM or not).
How Does It Play?
This is a question for you to answer. My goal was to create a digital tool that still felt like you were playing the tabletop RPG. I know there’s one on Stream, but I’ve never been able to play it. I can’t even tell you why. Was I supposed to pay a fee? Is it available only when announced? Do you have to receive more than a public announcement to be invited? I have reason to believe any one of those could be true, but I really have no idea which, if any, are. It never seems to be available to me when I’ve tried. I also had a desktop version from back in the early 2010s, and I appreciated it, but it played like a video game. You weren’t really managing the mechanics of the game yourself. If you want to play this, just navigate to the site and start playing against anyone else that wants to play. You don’t have to send me any money, and you don’t wait for me to tell you it’s okay. You just have to find a frenemy to destroy. Ideally, this will bring you back to the 80s and feel like you’re playing the TTRPG. Just please let me know if you find any bugs or even things that don’t represent good game play. But before you do . . . .
Preferably without the big hair.
It’s Not All Good News
There are some important limitations.
Basic, Advanced, and Graduate are largely good to go. Quirks aside, you can use the apps to run skirmishes in those rulesets right now. While you can run a game in the Command & Control ruleset, you still must run the entire ship from a single window. In other words, the entire point of C&C — several players being assigned only some of the bridge officer positions for a single ship — isn’t implemented. Moreover, Engineering Hit isn’t quite ready for C&C, which means neither systems nor bridge personnel are shaken. So, if you run a game in C&C, you should expect to do so only as a curiosity to see how far along it is and to experience things like the Skill Rolls phase.
As the game plays out, your web page will reload far more often than it should. You may be getting ready to arm weapons, then suddenly your page reloads and jumps back down to the weapons console because of something I did with my ship. It’s annoying as hell, but you’ll probably get used to it. You won’t have to live with it forever though. Seriously, be prepared to be annoyed.
Sometimes the system can get stuck in one way or another. Clicking the Refresh button at the top of the page, or just reloading and “resubmitting” the page should fix the problem.
Some of the sensor questions are missing, although most of them are questions I added that aren’t in the official rules.
Speaking of house rules, my intent is to design the game exactly as the rules state, then provide the GM a series of optional rules to implement. Those house rule sensor questions will no longer be there by default once those “switches” are implemented.
One of the switches will be to disable the manual rolling of dice. As of right now, every roll made can be done automatically by the system upon clicking a roll button or by manually entering the result of a physical die roll and clicking a Use Manual Roll button. I can imagine GMs wanting to ban manual rolls to reduce cheating, but for now, they can’t, so don’t cheat.
I’m going to add a Captain’s Console in all rulesets that gives a player playing the Captain direct involvement in the digital aspect of the game. It will also better organize the information near the top of the page.
Orion and Romulan ships can’t yet self-destruct. A GM will be able to allow any ship to self-destruct, but I currently plan for the default to allow Orions and Romulans to do so. The rules say Romulans only, but Journey to Babel suggests that Orions are willing to engage in suicide missions, so I’m allowing it by default. For now, if you don’t like that, simply agree among yourselves that Orion ships won’t self-destruct. No one’s ever forced to self-destruct.
In keeping with what’s happened on the original TV show, I’m going to add a switch allowing a bridge officer in C&C to abandon his post and take over another, more critical post for a shaken officer. That’s not technically within the official rules, though, so you really won’t miss it yet. This, of course, means that the replacement officer’s original post will go unmanned, preventing, for example, gathering more information through sensors. The lock won’t be broken, but the questions won’t be askable while the Science Officer is firing weapons. Additionally, the players get one free bite at the apple. The Captain can take over a station as needed, and the only consequence will be that the Captain can’t add a 1d10 to his or her Starship Combat Strategy/Tactics skill rating when determining tactical advantage. Again, this will all be optional, but it’s consistent with how the show was written, so it honestly should have been contemplated by the rules.
This one isn’t my fault. The Combat Efficiency (“CE”) system kind of sucks. I’m doing research and trying to piece together different alternatives for determining combat strength. Right now, the left side menu can display the CEs for all sides of the combat. I’ll add alternative measures of ship strengths when I compile them.
My current list of tasks is probably about 30 tasks long, so maybe any complaints you have that are not already listed here are in the queue anyway. I’ll eventually edit this post and show my pending task list so that you know what’s coming. Still, your comments are welcome. It can’t hurt to ask for things not knowing whether I’ve already thought of them.
Sample Scenarios: The White Flame Campaign
In the VTT, you can create, save, and load scenarios so that you can prepare for your game session ahead of time. These aren’t saved online; you save them to your hard drive as *.json files. If someone else wants to use your scenario, you can email them the rather small file(s). Speaking of which, I’ve created the scenarios for the White Flame supplement. Due to limitations in my WordPress account, I can’t upload them here and create links to them, and I’m not giving out links to my Dropbox account. Instead, I created separate pages that contain the contents of those *.json files. Simply copy the text for one file, then save it. The page title is the name I use for the file, but it doesn’t matter what you call them.
Note that loading a scenario currently wipes out the existing one, which means you can’t currently load a “second wave” (or subsequent wave) to a combat. That means that you’d have to take the time to load the subsequent waves in the middle of your session, or, as I’ve done, include them in the original session and ignore them until they need to be used. Also, some of these scenarios require that some ships start the scenario partially damaged, and freighters are carrying shipments that, if the freighter explodes, it does extra damage. Neither of those are implemented yet.
I saw Mandalorian and Grogu last night. I liked it. I thought it was fun in general, but I tend to like subversions of my expectations even if not particularly surprising, such as with Rotta the Hut. I won’t say anymore about that because, I don’t know, spoilers maybe?
Anyway, I have a fake war with my cousin, Kessel Junkie (kessel junkie?) over which is better, Star Trek or Star Wars. Of course, Star Trek is better, but watching the movie last night, I think Star Wars does something that, if not “better,” is “neater,” than Star Trek. I think they do a much cooler job of providing a wider variety of life forms. It’s still a human-dominated, and certainly humanoid-dominated, universe, but not nearly as much as Star Trek is. Even where Star Trek dealt with a crazy difference in environment (e.g., Excalbians) or fundamental chemical structure (e.g., Hortas), Star Trek was limited by budgets, but they’re willingly bound by pseudo-science as well.
If planets are roughly Class M (i.e., Earthlike), then even with independent evolution, it’s not unreasonable to assume most life will take on certain common characteristics as a matter of logic. This idea is called physical or biological convergent evolution, so while I haven’t done any deep dives into the subject matter, I’m not just pulling it out of my ass. For example, the best elements on which life should be based are carbon, silicon, or germanium. On a very fundamental level, we would be similar to most life forms because it would be far too difficult for a planet to be expected to have more silicon or (especially) germanium than carbon. Evolution would simply favor carbon based life. But, for example, basic eye structure exist for a reason, so there’s a possible practical limitation to just how different other life can be. Of course, it’s a big universe, so there have got to be exceptions, but the point is that aliens may be more like us than we think.
But that’s the difference between science fiction and science fantasy. (Fun) Star Trek fans thrive on pointing out then resolving inconsistencies, and even with nu-Trek, the writers have traditionally tried to remain consistent and logical across series with not only science but also with stories and history, including real world history. Sometimes, that very idea is what the episode’s story is about (e.g., Return to Tomorrow, The Chase, or Distant Origin). This doesn’t mean that Star Trek fans don’t like some occasional weirdness, but limits on that weirdness are sort of baked into the Star Trek community, and I like that. Star Wars has no such limits. As science fantasy, they can simply do what’s cool, and no one will even question it. Parsecs, smarsecs. I want a space slug, so I’m getting a space slug. I also like that.
Will Star Wars ever dethrone Star Trek for me? Of course not, but fortunately none of us need to choose between the two.
My work on my Bridge application has me contemplating all the ship designs I’ve seen in science fiction and science fantasy, and it reminded me of what my favorite design among them is. Unsurprisingly, it’s from Star Trek.
The Klingon D-7M Cruiser from the TOS movie era and beyond.
Now, let’s be crystal clear. I’m fully aware that this is 100% subjective. I’m not trying to convince anyone of anything other than to maybe mull it over and form your own opinion. However, I’m going to explain why I like it so much anyway. First, I think it emulates a jet fighter you might pilot. But in this regard, it probably isn’t any better than this ship from the FASA Star Trek RPG.
The Romulan T-10 (Bright One) Destroyer
I’ve always preferred the Romulans to the Klingons as enemies, but this one loses out (as do many other cool designs) to the D-7M for another reason: The backstory (or at least my preferred backstory) to the D-7’s design. I’ve heard a few theories as to why it has a long, thin neck separating the main hull from the bridge. First, it was to keep the poorly insulated ships from irradiating the command bubble. Second, it was to lower the forward profile of the ship when attacking, leaving it’s command center and devastating photon torpedo launcher less vulnerable to being disabled. The third explanation, though, is my favorite, and to my knowledge it comes from the Star Fleet Battles RPG that I played only once. That game positied the notion that the design made it harder to succeed in a mutiny. The thin neck was a natural bottleneck for subordinates trying to take over the command module. Also, it’s interior design had many obstacles built into it, requiring mutineerers to zigzag through the neck before getting to the command module. That gave plenty of time for the captain to detach the command module and blow up the main hull and neck before the mutineers could reach him. What’s more Klingon than that?
But ultimately, I simply like the aesthetic. As I said, this isn’t an argument.
I think Star Wars has had enough designs to come up with some really cool ones, but many are, surprisingly, more functional than creative in design. They’re closer to what I think an actual starship would look like if it were real, or maybe what you’d expect from a rebel alliance that’s repurposing far more available freighters as weapons of war. The FASA Star Trek RPG did a top notch job of expanding the Star Trek universe with some really great designs as well, but they just don’t top the D-7 for me. I should also mention that I haven’t watched a tremendous amount of science fiction and science fantasy, so maybe there’s something out there I’d like better. However, for now, the Klingons win this war. Seems appropriate.
As today is the real Star Wars Day and the only one that should be celebrated, I’ll tell you my story. Like all my childhood stories, there’s an element of sadness to it, but only in a “first world problem” sense. It’s not really a downer.
Star Wars: A New Hope was released eight days after my ninth birthday. I didn’t get to see it quickly, as it wasn’t a priority for my parents, and they didn’t want to wait in those ridiculous lines. However, the release was extended due to its popularity, so because they were interested in it themselves, I technically did see it when it was released. Unlike some of you, I don’t remember the exact date, but it was definitely (and obviously) during 1977.
My cousin, Kessel Junkie, and his older brother loved it, but their parents fostered that. They had the bed sheets, toys, etc. So, when it was re-released in the theaters, their parents planned to see it again. The day before, they were over at the house. I had helped out their mother in some way I don’t remember, and she returned me home. She asked me what I wanted in return. I responded, “Take me to see Star Wars.” Knowing how my family would react, I said it with deep and sincere sarcasm in my voice because I never imagined being able to see it in the theater a second time. Well, she enthusiastically responded, “Sure!” She knew that would absolutely pay the debt (so to speak) to me. My mother wasn’t pleased but was in a position where it would be awkward to disallow it. I’d pay for it later, but I didn’t care. So, I actually got to see it twice on the big screen. This was the nicest thing my aunt ever did for me (I don’t mean that as a backhanded compliment), and I always appreciated that.
Foreshadowing!
On Christmas of the year the Empire Strikes Back was released, Kessel Junkie‘s parents got me the novelization for Christmas. It was given to me at the large, extended family Christmas party we had every year, so there was no way to hide it. I immediately started reading it, ignoring the party, but obviously I couldn’t finish the entire novel that night. I was ridiculed every time I picked it up because it was childish (I was fucking 11 years old!), but because that didn’t work, it was confiscated within the week. I never did finish it. I imagine, just like many books, it improved on the story from the movie. I hadn’t thought about this in decades, so maybe I should buy and read it.
This wasn’t really the product of an anti-Star Wars attitude as much as it was just another excuse to crush my spirit, but they did even meaner things with Star Trek, so this had nothing to do with . . .
The “Rivalry”
Star Wars sucks!
“Star Trek >> Star Wars” is a phrase I use more than “My name is Rob,” but as Kessel Junkie will tell you, we’re both fans of both. I just prefer Star Trek, and he prefers Star Wars. But the only Star Wars that doesn’t appeal to me is the animated stuff (for reasons I’ve discussed before) and the Last Jedi (it reminds me too much of the OJ Simpson slow speed chase). Maybe my love of Star Trek is why Rogue One is my favorite Star Wars movie; it has a more Star Trek feel. In any event, don’t take it as an insult to the franchise. Star Wars continues to consistently put out great material, and they even adjust on the fly to cater to what the fans suddenly want to see (e.g., Ahsoka). To be fair, Star Trek did that with Strange New Worlds.
I really do love Star Wars, and you should never doubt that simply because . . .
Yeah, you read that right. Captain Kirk and William Shatner were both born on March 22. Shatner was born in 1931, and Kirk will be born in 2233. This may be out of place considering that I’m writing this post on May 7, 2022, and who knows what will happen to my captain (or me) between now and then, but I wish them both well . . .
My favorite episode of Star Trek, any series, is Balance of Terror from the original series. It has absolutely everything that a Star Trek episode should have, and it, along with my favorite Star Trek movie, the Wrath of Khan, inspired the best episode of Strange New Worlds to date, Memento Mori. For some reason, Balance of Terror keeps coming up in my social media streams. Several people keep saying something that prompts me to volunteer this information.
Or posting a silly meme.
But this post isn’t about Star Trek.
I set my mind to rewatch the episode but kept procrastinating. Yesterday, I was watching the Empire Strikes Back and Return of the Jedi. I love both of those movies. It occurred to me that none of the X-Wings, Tie-Fighters, etc. had any aft-firing weaponry. That would have been quite useful when being chased during the attacks on either Death Star. The Millennium Falcon sort of did, but only if there was at least one other person on the ship available to mad that blaster. (If I’m wrong, I’m sure Kessel Junkie will correct me.)
But wait! This post is about Star Trek!
This led me to finally re-watch Balance of Terror (re-watching Memento Mori will follow soon) in which I thought there was some background chatter stating that the aft-firing torpedoes are ready. (Note: I may have been mistaken, but there were mentions to aft-firing weapons in the background charter of several episodes, most clearly at 17:02 of Arena.) It also led to a cascade of thoughts regarding the hubbub about violating canon. I love the FASA Star Trek RPG, and it annoyed me that the Constitution Class starships didn’t have aft-firing weaponry. In fact, they made a big deal out of it. It was a glaring weakness in most Federation ships, and a big deal when some did. But it’s not all about an RPG. Star Trek the Motion Picture also suggested that the Klingon ship (also captained by Mark Lenard) having an aft-firing torpedo was a big deal. He thought it would surprise his enemy.
Right emotion; wrong guy.
And then there are those star dates that were completely made up, and the fact that the Romulan ship in Balance of Terror wasn’t capable of warp travel (22:10) yet traveled in interstellar space. In the two episodes I mentioned, there was an inconsistency. In Arena, Kirk comments that diamonds are “perhaps the hardest substance known in the universe” (30:10), and Spock confirms this by stating, “diamonds, the hardest known substance” (41:32), yet Spock points out only four episodes earlier in Balance of Terror that “cast rodinium . . . is the hardest substance known to our science” (21:26). Canon is shit. That’s unfortunate in most (not all) cases, but it’s true. You can’t rely on it. However, one theory says that there’s no such thing as a canon violation because Star Trek First Contact rebooted the franchise, rendering “canon” a nonsense concept.
I love to see Strange New Worlds show aft-firing phasers, see everyone lose their shit for the canon violation, and then lay into them for their ignorance. If everyone now realizes that the Enterprise has aft-firing weapons, that’s fine too. It gives us one more reason to say Star Trek ships are better than Star Wars ships.
Just roll with it and be happy when stories are well-written.
Sundays now are lazy days for me. I either post something silly or other people’s work. Usually both. Today, I share a tweet that reminded me of something else. (Image of the tweet appears at the end in case it’s ever deleted. ) To my knowledge, this tweet had nothing to do with RPGs. It was just a ridiculous design made for the sake of ridiculousness.
I will never apologize for a gratuitous Star Trek reference, however forced it may be.
Well, my post for this evening was accidentally scheduled for 6:30 am ET, so it went out before I got out of bed. No worries. I’m just throwing this one in as a follow up to provide proof of eating my first tacos in at least 17 years. That’s right. A patent issuing on the day I last had a taco has already expired.
I will never apologize for a gratuitous intellectual property law reference, however forced it may be.
But you need proof, so here it is.
When I saw the menu, the tacos were loaded with beef, so I didn’t think to order extra beef. What I got was rather light on the details. As a result, I had to eat some more when I got home.
But don’t worry (why would you even care?). The fact that these are from Taco BHell doesn’t guarantee that I’ll wait another 17 or so years before eating them again. Cheese will. Also, there’s one annoying thing about eating tacos that I had long forgotten: Take one bite, and the shell collapses. I had to shove them into my face, or everything would have fallen into my lap as I was eating. That’s a buzzkill because to me a taco isn’t a taco without crunch. If you eat soft tacos, there’s something wrong with you. Just eat a burrito or enchilada. There’s nothing wrong with that, but those aren’t tacos. Nothing with a soft shell is.
It bears repeating, but he’s wrong for including hard shell stuff.
I’ll still probably eat tacos before today’s patents expire, just not from Taco BHell.
And no, they’re not authentic Mexican food. Who cares, Francis?
Sundays now are lazy days for me. I either post something silly or other people’s work. Usually both. Today, it’s about a recent conversation. Strangely, a coworker asked me just this past week whether I enjoyed the Genesis concert from 11/18/2021. I told him . . . yeah.